Why Did Health Insurance Premiums Go Up? 7 Reasons for 2026

November 17, 2026
8 min read
Why Did Health Insurance Premiums Go Up? 7 Reasons for 2026
Table of contents
BG
Nisl dui hendrerit interdum

Ac quis vel auctor et pellentesque enim pretium sed commodo orci nulla.

Get Your Benefits Assessment
You’re overpaying for benefits. We’ll prove it.
Author

James Taylor

Founding Benefits Consultant, Ignition Benefits

Health insurance premiums went up in 2026 because of higher hospital prices, GLP-1 and specialty drug spending, heavier use of care and expiring ACA subsidies.
Key takeaways
  • Care got more expensive on every front at once. Hospital prices, spending on GLP-1 drugs and other specialty drugs, and heavier use of care (including behavioral health) pushed the health insurance premium increase in 2026 to the largest employer cost jump in 15 years.
  • The size of your increase depends on where you buy coverage. Employer family premiums rose 5% to $28,303, small group insurers proposed a median 11%, and ACA Marketplace insurers raised prices 26% as enhanced federal subsidies expired.
  • Small businesses take the hardest hits. A shrinking small group risk pool, pooled PEOs and single high-cost claims push many renewals into double digits. 39% of small and midsize businesses (SMBs) took a double-digit increase at their latest renewal.
  • Most drivers are structural, so 2027 looks worse. Projections run from 8.2% to 9.5% for employers and 14% for small group filings. The levers left belong to the employer: remarketing the plan, plan design, the funding model, an ICHRA or a PEO exit.
This is some text inside of a div block.
This is some text inside of a div block.
Lorem ipsum porta pharetra risus molestie sem diam.

Your renewal letter arrived with a double-digit number and a two-line explanation. You have company: 39% of SMBs took a double-digit increase at their last renewal, according to Ignition's Benefits Blind Spot survey of 503 leaders.

So, why did health insurance premiums go up? Hospitals charged more, drug spending climbed, people used more care, and insurers priced all three into 2026 rates. Small groups also absorbed a shrinking risk pool and federal policy changes.

Below, you'll find how much premiums rose by market, the seven reasons behind the increase, how to read your own renewal, and what to do before the next one arrives.

How Much Health Insurance Premiums Went Up in 2026

Premiums rose in every major market except Medicare Advantage in 2026. The size of the jump depended on where the coverage was bought.

Market 2026 Change What the Number Measures Source
Employer-sponsored family coverage Up 5%, to $28,303 a year Average total premium, employer and worker shares combined KFF 2026 Employer Health Benefits Survey
Employer health benefit cost per employee Up 6.7%, to more than $18,500 Average total cost per employee after planned plan changes Marsh National Survey of Employer-Sponsored Health Plans
Small group market (ACA-compliant plans for employers with up to 50 employees) Median proposed increase of 11% Median rate request across 318 insurers in all 50 states and DC Peterson-KFF Health System Tracker
ACA Marketplace (individual coverage) Up 26% on average What insurers charge before subsidies KFF
Medicare Advantage Down from $16.40 to $14.00 a month Average monthly plan premium across all plans CMS

This was an unusual year. Marsh projected 2026 as the highest employer cost increase in 15 years, following a decade of increases that averaged about 3%. Aon, which tracks actual plan costs, measured employer cost growth of 8.8% in 2026, to $14,432 per employee.

The Marketplace jump is the outlier. KFF estimates insurers added about 4 percentage points to 2026 Marketplace rates because they expected healthier people to leave once enhanced premium tax credits expired. That factor doesn't touch employer premiums.

Here's what those percentages mean in dollars. A 40-person company paying the KFF single-coverage average of $9,804 per employee spends about $392,000 a year. A 5% increase adds about $19,600. An 11% small group increase adds about $43,100. 

7 Reasons Why Health Insurance Premiums Increased

Insurers in the 2026 small group filings put underlying medical cost growth at about 9% before any other adjustment (Peterson-KFF). Seven forces sit behind that number. 

1. Hospital and Provider Prices Keep Climbing as Health Systems Consolidate

Hospital care made up 42% of spending for privately insured people in 2022, and hospitals charge commercial plans far more than Medicare pays. In 2022, employers and private insurers paid hospitals 254% of what Medicare would have paid for the same services, according to RAND. Eight states, including California, Florida, Georgia and New York, topped 300%.

Consolidation keeps those prices high. RAND found that hospital market power explains a large share of the price differences between hospitals. Marsh names health system consolidation as one of the forces driving up charges in employer plans.

For your company, that means every MRI, surgery or ER visit costs your plan about two and a half times the Medicare rate.

Temporary or structural: Structural. Large systems carry their pricing power into every contract negotiation with insurers.

2. GLP-1 and Specialty Drug Spending

GLP-1 use is growing faster than any other cost line. GLP-1 prescriptions filled in December 2025 were nearly double the December 2024 volume, according to PwC's Behind the Numbers report. Marsh's actuaries estimate rising GLP-1 use accounts for a full percentage point of employer cost growth in 2027.

Other specialty drugs add to the pressure. Hospital drug expenses rose 13.6% in 2025 (AHA), and employers named autoimmune and cancer therapies as leading specialty cost drivers (IFEBP).

Most employers can't see this line at all. Among companies whose plans cover GLP-1s, 58% can't say what the drugs add to their renewal, and only 11% know the exact amount (Benefits Blind Spot). You can't set a sound coverage policy for a cost you can't measure.

Temporary or structural: Structural for now. New competitors and oral versions could bring prices down, but demand keeps rising.

3. Heavier Use of Care, Including Behavioral Health

People are using more care, and insurers price that in. Marsh’s chief actuary said in 2025 that both components of cost trend, price and utilization, are rising at the same time.

Behavioral health shows the steepest climb. Claims for inpatient behavioral health services rose nearly 80%, and outpatient claims rose almost 40%, between January 2023 and December 2024 (PwC). One in three health plan actuaries named behavioral health a top-three cost driver for 2026. Small group insurers again listed higher utilization as a primary driver in their 2027 filings.

More claims per employee means a higher expected cost per employee. That's the starting point for every renewal quote.

Temporary or structural: Mostly structural. Demand built up over several years and hasn't reversed.

4. Healthcare Labor Costs and General Inflation

Hospitals pass their own rising costs on to insurers, and insurers pass them on to you. Workforce costs make up about 60% of hospital expenses and rose 5.6% in 2025. Total hospital expenses grew 7.5%, more than twice as fast as hospital prices, according to the American Hospital Association's 2026 Costs of Caring report. Supply costs rose 9.9%.

Hospitals recover those costs when they renegotiate commercial contracts. Insurers in the 2026 small group filings also cited broader inflation, labor shortages and uncertainty about tariff-driven cost increases (Peterson-KFF).

Temporary or structural: Partly temporary. Wage pressure can cool, but contracted rates already include this year's increases.

5. High-Cost Claims and Workforce Risk

In a small group, one or two expensive claims can reset the whole year's rate. Million-dollar claims rose 46% in frequency from 2022 to 2026, according to stop-loss insurer Sun Life. Aon lists the growing number of high-cost claims among the core drivers of employer spending.

Carriers also price your census: the age, gender and location of every employee. Each employee who turns a year older raises the age-rated cost of the plan, even if nobody files a claim. Carriers turn all of this into a risk score for your group. You rarely get to see it.

This is the main reason your increase can be bigger, or smaller, than the headline average. A young, healthy team with a low risk score that still gets a double-digit increase is likely overpaying.

Temporary or structural: Varies by group. It changes every year with your claims and your census.

6. Federal Policy Changes

The largest policy shock hit the individual market. Enhanced ACA premium tax credits expired at the end of 2025. Average monthly Marketplace premium payments rose 58%, from $113 to $178, and enrollment fell for the first time in seven years (KFF).

Employers feel policy changes indirectly. Marsh links lower government funding and reimbursements in public programs to higher charges in employer plans, as providers make up the difference with commercial payers. Marsh also estimates that disputes under the No Surprises Act, the federal law that bans most surprise out-of-network bills and sends insurer-provider payment disputes to arbitration, add up to a percentage point to 2027 costs.

If you fund an ICHRA, the Marketplace changes hit you directly, since your employees buy individual coverage.

Temporary or structural: Mixed. Subsidy expiration was a one-time shift. Cost shifting from public programs to commercial plans is structural.

7. A Shrinking Small Group Risk Pool

The fully insured small group market keeps losing its healthiest members. Enrollment fell from 17 million people in 2013 to 10 million in 2024 (Peterson-KFF). Healthier groups move to level-funded and self-funded plans, and the groups that stay carry a higher average risk. KFF researchers warn that continued growth in level-funded plans could erode the pool further.

The cost gap is already wide. Fully insured plans cost $8,005 per employee, compared with $5,914 for level-funded or self-funded plans, according to the Benefits Blind Spot survey. At 40 employees, that's about $83,600 a year, enough to fund another hire.

PEO pools work the same way: a healthy startup pays rates set by every other client in the pool. Companies on PEOs reported double-digit renewal increases more often than companies working directly with a carrier or broker (49% vs. 34%).

Temporary or structural: Structural. Each healthy group that leaves raises the average risk for the groups that stay. Our guide to fully insured plans explains how this pricing works.

How to Read Your Renewal Increase

Every renewal number combines three parts: market trend, your group's own experience, and plan changes. Most renewal letters show only the total. Only 31% of SMBs received a clear breakdown of what drove their last increase.

Here's how an 18% renewal might split. The numbers are illustrative.

Component Share of Increase What it Covers
Market trend 9% Price and utilization growth across the carrier's whole book of business
Group experience and census 6% Your claims, large claimants, and changes in employee age and location
Plan and pricing changes 3% Benefit changes, pharmacy changes and new fees

The market trend piece tracks the industry average. The other two pieces are where your increase pulls away from it, and where you have room to push back.

In the first 48 hours after the letter arrives, send these questions back to your broker:

  • How much of the increase is market trend, and how much is our own claims experience?
  • Did one or two large claims drive the experience piece? Are those people still on the plan?
  • How much comes from census changes, such as age, headcount or location?
  • What plan, network or pharmacy changes are included, including GLP-1 coverage?
  • How many carriers did you quote, and can we see every quote side by side?
  • What would level-funded or self-funded pricing look like for our census?
  • What's the deadline to accept or change the plan?

Ask the carrier-count question first. 38% of SMBs compared two or fewer carriers at their last renewal. If the answer is one or two, you haven't seen the market. 

What Employers Can Do About Rising Premiums

You can't control hospital prices or drug launches. You can control where your plan is priced, how it's funded and what it covers. Most SMBs never use those levers: 48% paid at or close to the first number their insurer quoted, and only 6% have ever run an independent review of their benefits costs (Benefits Blind Spot).

The stakes go beyond the benefits line. 64% of SMBs made a business trade-off to cover their last increase, most often cutting the raise and bonus budget. 53% say rising healthcare costs have made it harder to compete for talent. For a fuller playbook, see our guide on how to reduce small business health insurance costs.

1. Remarket the Plan Across Every Carrier

Take the plan to every carrier that writes coverage in your state, priced against your actual census. Your incumbent carrier's renewal is one quote. You only see the full range of prices if someone requests every quote.

Best fit: Any company that has renewed twice without a full market review.

2. Adjust Plan Design and Contributions

Raise deductibles, add a lower-cost plan option, change networks or adjust the employer contribution. Marsh found that 59% of employers plan cost-cutting plan changes for 2027. These moves cut premium, but they shift cost to employees, which works against hiring.

Best fit: Companies that need relief at this renewal and can protect the core plan employees value most.

3. Change the Funding Model

A level-funded plan charges a fixed monthly amount that covers expected claims, administration and stop-loss insurance (coverage that caps your exposure to large claims). If claims come in under budget, part of the surplus can come back to you. A self-funded plan pays claims directly, with stop-loss protection above a set amount.

Small firms already use these models widely. Among covered workers at firms with 10 to 199 employees, 38% are in level-funded plans and 25% are in self-funded plans (KFF). The trade-off: a bad claims year raises your cost the following year. Compare the models in our guides to level-funded vs. fully insured plans and self-funding.

Best fit: Younger, healthier teams whose risk score sits well below what their fully insured premium implies.

4. Move to an ICHRA

An ICHRA gives each employee a tax-free monthly allowance to buy individual coverage. You set a fixed budget, and employees choose their own plans. Marketplace prices rose 26% in 2026, so check local premiums before you switch. Learn how the setup works in our ICHRA guide.

Best fit: Distributed teams spread across many states, or groups whose small group quotes run far above local Marketplace prices.

5. Leave a PEO

A PEO bundles payroll, HR and benefits, and pools your employees with every other client for pricing. That pooling gets more expensive as you grow. Companies on PEOs were twice as likely as companies working directly with a carrier or broker to delay or cancel hires to cover their last increase (23% vs. 10%). As headcount approaches 50, a plan priced on your own workforce often beats pool pricing. See how a PEO transition works.

Best fit: Companies at or approaching 50 employees with a healthy workforce on a PEO plan.

How Ignition finds the gap. Ignition pulls your Benefits Risk Score, the same risk model carriers already use to price your renewal, before going to market. Then we run a full-market audit: every carrier, every plan and every funding structure, with no preferred carriers.

You get a Benefits Analysis Report in 14 to 21 days, compared with the 8 to 12 weeks a traditional broker review takes. Your part is two 15-minute calls. When premiums are high and the risk score is low, the report shows exactly how much you're overpaying.

Will Health Insurance Premiums Keep Going Up in 2027?

Yes. Every major 2027 projection matches or tops this year's increase, and employer health insurance costs in 2026 already set a 15-year record.

Small group insurers have proposed a median 14% increase for 2027 across 295 rate filings, up from 11% for 2026 (Peterson-KFF). That would make the small business health insurance increase double digits for a second year in a row. 

The drivers behind these numbers are structural, so they won't reverse on their own. The levers you control (where the plan is priced, how it's funded and what data you see before renewal) matter more each year. 

Conclusion

Find Out Why Your Premium Went Up With Ignition

Market trend explains the average increase. Your group's own data explains the rest: your risk score, your claims and your census. Carriers see that data at every renewal. Most employers never do.

Ignition's free 15-minute review shows you what your carrier sees, where your renewal sits against the market, and whether you're paying for risk your team doesn't carry. As an employee benefits broker built for founders and CFOs, Ignition handles the analysis. You bring your census and current plan.

Learn why your premium went up.

FAQs

What State Has the Cheapest Health Insurance?

New Hampshire, for individual Marketplace coverage. Its 2026 average benchmark premium was $401 a month for a 40-year-old, the lowest of any state (KFF).

What Is the Least Expensive Way to Get Health Insurance?

Usually through an employer. In 2026, covered workers paid $1,672 a year on average for single coverage, about 17% of the $9,804 premium (KFF).

Why Is Health Insurance So Expensive?

High prices drive most of it. U.S. private plans paid hospitals 254% of Medicare rates in 2022 (RAND), and drug spending and use of care keep rising.

You’re overpaying for benefits. We’ll prove it.